1. Ty Detmer
College stats: QBR 162.7, Passing TDs 121, 15031 passing yards, Completion Percentage 62.6, INT 65
Awards:
Heisman Trophy (1990)
Maxwell Award (1990)
2x Davey O’Brien Award (1990-1991)
UPI Player of the Year (1990)
2x Consensus All-American (1990-1991)
Heisman Trophy finalist (1991)
Why vote for him? Statistically speaking Ty is one of the most productive quarterbacks not just in the state but in college football history. He passed for the fifth most yards In NCAA history and tied for the 8th most touchdowns. He was a Heisman winning quarterback and was one of the most successful quarterbacks in the golden era of BYU passers. He played under center in one of the biggest wins in program history when BYU upset the #1 ranked Miami Hurricanes.
#16 Matt Gay
College Stats: Field goals made 56, 56 yard longest field goal, 253 total points
Awards:
Consensus All-American (2017)
Lou Groza Award: (2017)
2x First Team All-PAC-12 (2017-2018)
Why vote for him?
Never underestimate the power of a kicker! May Gay is one of the best kickers in State history and has set records. If any kicker can stand up to BYU, it is Gay. Vote for Matt if you believe in the finesse of field goals, the power of a punter and the charisma of a kicker.
Of course the obvious choice is Ty Detmer! Really?! There is NO debate!